LLI at Labour conference 2024

LLI will be in Liverpool for the Labour conferences 21-25 September.

Download our bulletin for the conference.

To join the WhatsApp group for LLI people at the conference

http://bit.ly/lli-wa

Our fringe meeting at conference

Tax the rich for socialist policies; rebuild the Labour left
Monday September 23rd, 6.30 pm
Maria Exall (ex-President, TUC)
Jane Stewart (formerly women’s rep of Unite Executive council).
And representatives from key labour movement campaigns – speakers invited from Labour Campaign for Council Housing, Pride in Labour, Ukraine Solidarity Campaign and Labour Campaign for Free Movement

Other highlights of the fringe
Saturday PSC Palestine demo –- 12 noon St George’s Plateau, next to Lime St station
Campaign for Labour Party Democracy – 6:30pm, Friends Meeting House
Sunday NHS demo – 11.30 by the arch outside dock complex near ACC
Peoples’s Assembly Tax the Rich demo – 12 noon outside the ACC
Labour Campaign for Free Movement – protest 1pm and fringe meeting 6pm, The Botanist, Chavasse Park, Liverpool One, L2 9SQ
Monday Labour Campaign for Council Housing – 1pm, Friends Meeting House
Tuesday Labour for Trans Rights – rally outside ACC 10am
Socialist Education Association & Socialist HealthAssociation – 6pm,
Friends Meeting House
Pride in Labour – 6:30pm Yates, Queen Square,Liverpool L1 1RH
Campaign for Labour Party Democracy – 6:30pm Friends Meeting House

The right to strike

Motion passed by Bloomsbury & King’s Cross LP branch (Holborn & St. Pancras CLP) – not for LP conference 2024, but for your information

This branch notes: 

1) The government’s commitment government’s commitment to repeal the Strikes (Minimum Service Levels) Act 2023 

2) Reports that the government also plans to repeal the Trade Union Act 2016. 

3) The myriad other laws restricting strikes, including prohibition of action in solidarity with other workers. 

This branch further notes: 

1) Our CLP’s January 2024 resolution to “oppose the Minimum Service Levels Act and other anti-trade union legislation.” 

2) The CWU Greater London Combined (Telecoms) branch’s charter, calling for renewed campaigning to expand workers’ and union rights. 

3) The call for the full repeal of anti-strike laws, and their replacement with positive rights, is the policy of the majority of the labour movement, including the TUC and all Labour-affiliated unions. 

4) The upcoming TUC Congress will discuss submissions from the FBU and Usdaw reaffirming support for the repeal of all anti-union laws. 

This branch believes: 

1) The right to strike is a fundamental civil liberty. 

This branch resolves:

1) To call on the government to firmly commit to repealing the Trade Union Act 2016, and to go further by repealing other anti-strike legislation, such as the Employment Act 1980, which prohibits solidarity action.

2) To write to relevant reps on the NEC and NPF to express the view of the local party. 

3) To make a submission to the next NPF process in line with this policy. 

4) To invite a speaker from CWU Greater London Combined branch to address a future meeting about their branch’s charter.

Back “centre-left” candidates for NEC, NPF, NCC, and WCAC

Labour Left Internationalists calls on Labour members to vote for the “centre-left” candidates for the NEC and NPF (in ballots 27 Aug to 17 Sep) and for the NCC and WCAC (in ballots at Labour’s general conference and women’s conference).

For he list of “centre-left” candidates click here

The votes for the NCC and WCAC will be at the conferences. For NEC and NPF, ballots will open 27 August and close at midday on 17 September. Results 18 September, 5pm.

Two-child benefit cap, trans rights, housing, Palestine: statements seeking signatories, and template motions

Momentum is circulating a template motion for Labour’s September conference against the two-child benefit cap.

https://peoplesmomentum.com/wp-content/uploads/Abolish-the-Two-Child-Benefit-Cap-%E2%80%93-Motion-to-2024-Labour-Party-National-Conference.pdf

Leeds Young Labour has put out a statement against the two-child benefit cap https://forms.gle/vziN9KHNKmDbwxCN8

LAAA and Arise are circulating a statement of protest against the suspension from the whip of seven Labour MPs for voting for immediate lifting of the two-child benefit cap.

https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/keir-starmer-reverse-the-7-mps-suspension

The Labour Campaign for Council Housing has a template motion

Labour for Trans Rights has sent out a template motion and an statement seeking signatures against Wes Streeting’s announcement that he will continue a Tory ban on puberty blockers.

bit.ly/ltr-m

bit.ly/ltr-o

The motion is not in suitable format to comply with the reintroduced “Contemporary Motions” rule for Labour conference: see below for a well-formated motion put in Stockton North CLP.

The usually-conformist LGBT+ Labour group has written to Wes Streeting to protest, and a new group, Pride in Labour, has declared itself as wanting a more combative protest.

https://www.prideinlabour.org.uk/

https://labourlist.org/2024/07/labour-trans-row-lgbt-splinter-group/

And we ourselves, Labour Left Internationalists, have launched a statement seeking signatures calling for the Labour government to give practical effect to its nominal policy for a ceasefire and reconstruction in Gaza.

bit.ly/pal-p

Motion on trans rights submitted by Stockton North CLP

Conference notes:

That previous Labour governments introduced policies which protected the rights of trans people, including the 2004 Gender Recognition Act and the 2010 Equality Act.

On 12 July Wes Streeting signalled a permanent puberty blocker ban.

Hate crimes against trans people have risen by 186% in the last 5 years, according to ONS statistics.

Average waiting times to access healthcare at the majority of NHS gender identity clinics at least doubled between 2018 and 2023, with many waiting more than five years for their first appointment.

The UK’s system of gender recognition is difficult and degrading to navigate, with a European Commission study of 2020 finding that the UK is the second most difficult country in Europe for trans people to legally transition.

Conference resolves

To condemn the growth of divisive and demonising rhetoric about trans people in society, and express our solidarity and support for the trans community.

To affirm that trans women are women, and trans men are men.

To call on our new Labour cabinet to commit to reducing waiting lists to access gender identity clinics to the NHS 18 week target.

To call on our Labour cabinet to ban all forms of conversion therapy including a ban on this practice being carried out against transgender youth.

To adopt a definition of transphobia, based on the definition advocated for by TransActual and Labour for Trans Rights which is already used in transphobia training for CLPs.

(Other versions of this text have included a direct call to lift the ban on puberty blockers)

Labour MPs tell the CLPs to shut up

Ann Black’s report from the 23 July 2024 meeting of Labour’s National Executive tells us:

“Some members argued that the guidance on contemporary motions was unduly restrictive, limiting them to events after July 4th, but Parliamentary Labour Party representatives said that CLP delegates do not want big arguments or new policies”.

However, the NEC withdrew its previous statement that the motions must be on issues that cannot have been considered by the National Policy Forum. That restriction is now lifted.

But already:

In one CLP, the chair barred all motions submitted for conference from discussion in the CLP on the grounds that they were “out of order”. Even at the worst of the previous period of the rule that motions must be “contemporary”, CLP chairs left such “ruling out” to the Conference Arrangements Committee, and attempted no such “pre-censorship”.

In another CLP, a motion for decriminalisation of abortion, citing events since 5 July, was passed, but with many members seeming resigned to it being ruled out of order.

The “contemporary motions” rule is slippery. At times it has been used to rule hundreds of motions out of order; at other times, motions get to conference floor with little more trouble than adding a token reference to recent events.

Ann Black’s report indicates that this year the Labour Party apparatus is set on using the rule to exclude anything that might generate “big argument”.

Two conclusions follow.

CLPs should be bold about submitting motions which comply with any sensible interpretation of the rule but do raise “big arguments”. Even the current Labour regime will feel embarrassed and under pressure if it ends up ruling out almost all the motions submitted.

Affiliated unions should pay attention. In recent years, unions have pressed the Labour leadership on worker and union rights (the “New Deal”), but, as a tacit or explicit quid-pro-quo, have been quiet about other issues, even those of most urgent interest to union and working-class households such as the two-child benefit cap and the NHS.

The unions have seen leadership moves to silence the CLPs before: in 1997, with the Partnership in Power rule changes, and in 2007, with Gordon Brown’s move to abolish motions to conference altogether. Each time the unions eventually came round to restoring CLP rights, at least partially – with the 2003 rule change which restored a CLP say in conference debates after 1997, with the 2009 rule change which restored motions after 2007, and with the rule change in the Ed Miliband years which enabled conference to “refer back” sections of a National Policy Forum report.

The unions need to watch out for the new drive to suppress CLP voices.

Ann Black’s report also comments on Labour’s use of centralised control of IT to stop Labour members doing election work in some constituencies (reckoned safe), with the aim of forcing them to work instead in more marginal “target” seats.

No amount of such manipulation of members, Ann Black comments, will “move them en masse 50 miles [or more] down the road. Instead, some did nothing, and will do less when we need them in future. Local parties particularly resented losing access to [centrally-controlled IT for campaigning] without warning, even when they were fully meeting their twinning obligations.

“One CLP officer, prevented from organising any polling day activity, reported 25 members who were over 80 and would sit outside polling stations, but not make three-hour round trips…

“Some CLPs kept local activity below the radar, and even won through their own enterprise without party IT tools…”

Text which may be useful for Labour Party conference motions 2024

New deadlines:

for CLP delegates (to women’s and general conf) and NEC etc. nominations noon, 31 July
for women’s conference motions, 21 August
for general conference motions, Wednesday 12 Sep.

Women’s conference is 21 Sep, general conference 22-25 Sep, in Liverpool.

See below for suggested texts from LLI which you can adapt and a text from the Labour Campaign for Free Movement.

This year the rules once again require that motions be “contemporary” (meaning about things after 5 July).

Originally CLPs were also told that motions could not cover things already “considered” in NPF (or NEC) reports.

That restriction has been lifted. But even the remaining “contemporary” requirement is slippery. In the Ed Miliband era it was used to rule out hundreds of motions; in the early Corbyn years, less so. We have to try at least to give our texts a chance of getting through the net.

As usual, rules also require that motions be no more than 250 words “only on one subject” (that’s a slippery requirement, too), and not on “organisational matters”.

Those constraints, and an estimate that they are likely to be imposed more sharply this year than in the past, shape the wordings suggested below. Both texts are less than 250 words, to give you some leeway. We will update the texts as and when more “contemporary” events allow.


Abortion rights

Conference notes:

  1. The report on 17 July in Marie-Claire magazine that “Katie”, a woman who took abortion pills not knowing how far advanced her pregnancy was, faces trial this year.
  2. The joint letter to the Home Secretary on 19 July from RCOG, BPAS, FRSH, and MSI Reproductive Choices, calling for urgent introduction in England of safe access zones round abortion clinics in line with March 2023 legislation
  3. Our National Policy Forum stated that “Labour believes that abortion is an essential part of health care which is highly regulated and should not be subjected to custodial sanctions. Labour will provide parliamentary time for free votes on modernising abortion law to ensure women do not go to jail for getting an abortion at a vulnerable time”, but left for further consideration how that modernisation would be done.
  4. Current law, from 1861, still allows for women to be jailed for getting late abortions
  5. Diana Johnson MP’s amendment to remove such criminal sanctions fell with the calling of the General Election on 22 May and the consequent abandonment of the Criminal Justice Bill
  6. France’s vote in March 2024 to write the right to abortion into its constitution
  7. The Scottish Parliament’s vote, with Labour support, in June 2024 to introduce safe access zones around abortion clinics.

Conference therefore calls for speedy action to decriminalise abortion; to ensure that abortion provision is readily available to those who need it as other health care is; and to implement safe zones around abortion clinics.

246 words

Raising taxes to fund the NHS

Conference notes:

• On 17 July, NHS Greater Manchester formally accepted “enforcement undertakings” from NHS England.

• On 11 July the Doctors’ Association UK wrote to the Darzi review demanding “a commitment from NHSE and the government to significantly uplift core funding and continue to do so in line with inflation”.

• On 22 July a Labour official told the FT that the condition of public finances inherited from the Tories is “much, much worse that we thought it was going to be”.

• On 9 July HMRC reported “continued evidence of a recovery in numbers of non-domiciled taxpayers since the height of the Covid-19 pandemic”.

• On 7 June Tax Justice UK identified ten tax reforms, outside raising the main income tax, VAT, etc. rates, which would raise £60 billion a year for public services.

• Our National Policy Forum report stated that Labour will “tax fairly”, but left for further consideration the detail of how to do that, in an era of rising inequality

• Increased public investment is an essential lever for growth such as will bring tax revenues, but it requires funds upfront.

• Taxes on wealth and capital gains would affect few ordinary-income households, and make the tax system fairer.

Conference therefore calls for such tax rises focused on the wealthy to fund restoring the NHS and other public services.

(215 words)

Labour Campaign for Free Movement template motion

For a fair and humane immigration policy 

Conference notes the government’s commitment, outlined in the King’s Speech on 17th July, to introduce a Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill; a Migration Advisory Committee report on 16th July which highlighted exploitation of Seasonal Workers; and reports on 15th July of protests by refugees living on the Bibby Stockholm.

The Tories gave the UK an inhumane, regressive border regime, seeking to scapegoat migrants for the misery caused by austerity and deregulation. Restricting migrant rights makes people more precarious, undermining all workers’ power to push back against exploitation.

The 2023 NPF report commits Labour to conduct “a full review of the “hostile environment”. In reviewing the Hostile Environment, Labour must begin by reversing the legacy of Tory cruelty. This means going further than the King’s Speech.

Before conference 2025, Labour will:

  • repeal the Safety of Rwanda Act 2024, Illegal Migration Act 2023, Nationality and Borders Act 2022, and Immigration Acts 2014 and 2016
  • guarantee safe and legal routes for asylum seekers
  • give asylum seekers day-one rights to work, education, social security and family reunion
  • abolish “no recourse to public funds” and NHS charges

Before the next general election, Labour will:

  • level up domestic workers’ rights
  • grant all UK residents equal voting rights
  • end immigration raids, detention and deportations
  • introduce a simple process for all residents to gain permanent residency
  • end “double sentencing”
  • pursue agreements with other countries giving rights to travel, live, work and study without a visa